The cemetery was founded in 1823, with the first known burial being that of Margaret Milne, who died January 16, 1830. There are almost certainly older burials, either now unmarked or with unreadable headstones. As of today, there are at least 320 interments in the cemetery.
Directly behind the church, about 75 feet straight east, are a pair of zinc headstones, this, the larger of the two, the headstone of Mary Eliza Terry. Mary passed away in 1887 at the age of 32. Her headstone takes the form of a small obelisk with a two stepped, rusticated base. Made without removable inscription plates, the inscription is embossed on the shaft of the obelisk.
MARY
ELIZA
TERRY.
DIED
FEBY. 21, 1887,
AGED 32 YEARS.